Major League Baseball

Dodgers-Giants: A prized fight that never stopped giving

Updated Oct. 15, 2021 7:28 p.m. ET

By Martin Rogers
FOX Sports Columnist

There are so many different ways that it could have ended, this glorious, emotional, dramatic, season-long slugfest between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the San Francisco Giants.

Virtually all of them would have seemed more appropriate.

Deep into Thursday night, Max Scherzer — pressed into action as the Dodgers’ closer — threw a pitch to Giants first baseman Wilmer Flores with L.A. leading 2-1 in the ninth inning and two strikes on the board.

Flores checked his swing but was called out anyway, and that’s all she wrote — after six-and-a-half months, 24 games, an incredible arm-wrestle of a divisional race and a compelling struggle of a National League Divisional Series.

Colin Cowherd on Dodgers' win: 'The check-swing call was almost an appropriate end to the series' I THE HERD

The Los Angeles Dodgers advance to the National League Championship Series on a check-swing call on Wilmer Flores of the San Francisco Giants. Colin Cowherd lays out why the controversial call was almost a fitting end to the series.

It should have shaken out some other way, we felt. A walk-off dinger, perhaps. A spectacular play in the field. Or at least a fiery fastball to close the game on a strikeout.

That would have been nice, sure. Yet in truth, however this intriguing battle wound up, there would have been a sense of regret at seeing it pass us by, for it has been baseball’s golden balm all year.

It feels somewhat strange that the finish of this battle between a 107-win team and another that collected 106 isn’t the end of the season. No, there are still two gripping championship series matchups to come and then the Fall Classic itself.

That one of those combatants, the Giants, is now on the outside looking in scarcely seems fair, but that’s baseball, and that’s just how rare this was, that the Dodgers could be the second-best team in the sport yet land in the wild card.

It has been incredible, frankly, this ongoing war between two franchises that share so much history, dating all the way to when they both resided on the other side of the country and extending to the modern links, with Giants manager Gabe Kapler and president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi both having cut their teeth in the blue-hued system.

Baseball’s regular season has rarely been as good as this, and it was because of a pair of factors. Across the majors, a crew of exhilarating youngsters, led by Shohei Ohtani, did unfeasible things and did them with style and flourish. Then you had the ongoing battle in the NL West, which was a prize fight that never stopped giving.

Max Scherzer strikes out Wilmer Flores to seal Dodgers' 2-1 victory over Giants in game five of NLDS

Max Scherzer and the Los Angeles Dodgers won the NLDS in five games and will face the Braves in the NLCS.

It was supposed to look like something else. The Giants were no one’s idea of a contender, predicted to finish low in the pecking order with a lineup that lacked superstar firepower. The head-to-head NL West battle, wisdom suggested, would be between the Dodgers and the San Diego Padres, who came with big spending, a ton of belief and the magic of Fernando Tatis Jr.

Not so. The Giants got going early, and what started as a cute, little spring tussle continued throughout, gaining in gravitas all the while. The Dodgers were so loaded that the total falloff in form of 2019 NL MVP Cody Bellinger and a late-campaign injury to Clayton Kershaw were mere blips. The Giants saw sensational productivity from so many that it feels unfair to select a handful, such as Brandon Crawford, Buster Posey and LaMonte Wade Jr.

There was mutual respect between the teams, for how could there not be? Who better to appreciate just how difficult it is to win so many games than the opponent doing virtually the same thing?

"It’s personal to them, so it’s personal to us," Scherzer said. "We want to win, we respect the heck out of the Giants and how good they are, but you got to go out there and believe that you can beat them."

The Dodgers, ultimately, had too much firepower, with a roster stacked deep. Even so, the Giants pushed them to the brink and forced them to go for analytics rather than convention in Game 5, starting with relievers so that Julio Urías could enter in the third inning with the game still scoreless.

It was tense and tight, and how appropriate that it was. Baseball goes as it goes, but it would have been an anomaly if two teams that nipped at each other’s heels all year wrapped things up with a blowout.

Logan Webb was imperious for the Giants, Urias gave up just a single homer, and finally, in a twist that was in some ways unexpected and in some ways anything but, Bellinger, the former rock of the lineup coming off a horrid season, recorded the decisive RBI.

Cody Bellinger hits clutch go-ahead RBI-single to give Dodgers lead over Giants, 2-1

Cody Bellinger hit a clutch go-ahead single to put the Los Angeles Dodgers ahead 2-1 over the San Francisco Giants in the ninth inning of Game 5 of the NLDS.

What the Giants and the Dodgers gave fans this year was a stunning treat that no one predicted. It was the best of what sports can offer, a tussle of the minds, a fierce clash of wills, a gripping narrative and a matchup decided by the narrowest of margins after the longest time.

Baseball’s tales unfold gradually, and they’re sometimes a slow burn, but this one wasn’t. It was a fight that started strong and just kept getting better, more addicting, even more watchable, all the way to the end.

So yes, when Flores held up, the first base ump shouldn’t have called it. The story should have had a little more to it. But the real sadness wasn’t that there was a blown call, but rather, that it had to end at all.

Martin Rogers is a columnist for FOX Sports and the author of the FOX Sports Insider Newsletter. You can subscribe to the newsletter here.