National Football League

Gridiron Grades: NFL Week 1 QB analysis; Week 2 odds, predictions

Published Sep. 13, 2023 6:48 p.m. ET

share

facebookxredditlink

Colin Cowherd had a keen eye on the quarterback position during Week 1 of the 2023 NFL season — specifically, a few new faces in new places. 

On Tuesday's edition of "The Herd," Cowherd delivered his grades for the rookie signal-callers, a couple of new starters, and a handful of veterans taking the field in a different city.

Check out Colin's grades and thoughts, as well as the odds to know about each QB and their team.

C.J. STROUD, Houston Texans

Grade: C

Colin's thoughts: "He got pressured a ton. Only Daniel Jones faced more pressure. Rookie. A lot of pressure. He was fine."

Odds to know: At +650, the Texans have the second-shortest odds to be the last remaining winless team (FanDuel Sportsbook).

ANTHONY RICHARDSON, Indianapolis Colts

Grade: B+

Colin's thoughts: "Almost an A. He did throw a bad pick late. But three pass plays of over 20 yards. He led the Colts in rushing. I thought really a dynamic player. I was impressed with him."

Odds to know: Richardson currently has the second-shortest odds to win Offensive Rookie of the Year at +600 (FDS).

BRYCE YOUNG, Carolina Panthers

Grade: D

Colin's thoughts: "I don't think he's working with much, but he had the lowest completion percentage of the three rookie quarterbacks."

Odds to know: Young is tied for the third-shortest odds to lead the league in regular-season interceptions at +1100 (FDS).

JIMMY GAROPPOLO, Las Vegas Raiders

Grade: B+

Colin's thoughts: "Been there, accurate, gets it out. You're not gonna any stuff off the script."

Odds to know: The Bills (0-1) are 8.5-point favorites over the Raiders (1-0) in Week 2.

SAM HOWELL, Washington Commanders

Grade: C+

Colin's thoughts: "Not working with much. He was the second most-sacked quarterback. What are you gonna do? I think he's basically a less-talented Baker Mayfield."

Odds to know: The Commanders have the third-shortest odds to score the fewest points in Week 2 at +1000 (FDS).

JOSH DOBBS, Arizona Cardinals

Grade: C-

Colin's thoughts: "One of five quarterbacks not leading his team to an offensive touchdown. He's got some talent, but I'm not sure if he's a franchise quarterback."

Odds to know: At +1200, the Cardinals have the shortest odds to go 0-17 in the regular season (DraftKings Sportsbook).

Jordan Love, Baker Mayfield highlight Colin's Week 1 QB grades

DESMOND RIDDER, Atlanta Falcons

Grade: B

Colin's thoughts: "He completed 83% of his throws. Drake London didn't have a catch and Kyle Pitts had two. When you complete over eight out of 10 passes, I gotta give you a B."

Odds to know: At +12000, Ridder has the longest odds of all starting quarterbacks to lead the league in passing TDs (FDS).

DEREK CARR, New Orleans Saints

Grade: C+

Colin's thoughts: "Am I being too tough? He was 1-for-7 in the red zone, and I like Derek Carr. That's where you make your money in this league. That's the moneymaker. You gotta be good in the red zone."

Odds to know: Somewhat shockingly, the Saints have the sixth-shortest odds to be the last remaining undefeated team in the league at +1200 (FDS).

BAKER MAYFIELD, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Grade: C

Colin's thoughts: "He was awful early, very solid late. Didn't have much of a run game. Only averaged 3.6 yards a play and they do have some good offensive pieces. So there are limitations."

Odds to know: The Buccaneers' Over/Under win total for the 2023 regular season is 7.5, after going 8-9 in 2022 (DKS).

BROCK PURDY, San Francisco 49ers

Grade: A

Colin's thoughts: "I thought he was terrific. Six scoring drives. Only Tua had more scoring drives on the road against Pittsburgh. And the other thing is, he's a little bit more athletic than I give him credit for."

Odds to know: After Week 1, Purdy has the 10th-best NFL MVP odds at +2000. At +550, his 49ers have the shortest odds to finish the regular season with the best record in the NFL (FDS).

KENNY PICKETT, Pittsburgh Steelers

Grade: D

Colin's thoughts: "One scoring drive … with that talent? By the way, he was brutal on third down. You know what his passer rating was on third down? Fourteen! And again, that's a money down."

Odds to know: At +750, the Steelers have the longest odds to win the NFC North this season (DKS).

DESHAUN WATSON, Cleveland Browns

Grade: C-

Colin's thoughts: "It wasn't pretty. And he was only pressured five out of the 32 dropbacks. He had plenty of time. … I don't see it."

Odds to know: Watson has the second-shortest odds to throw the most passing yards (+250) and most passing touchdowns (+550) in the NFC North, trailing only Cincinnati's Joe Burrow (DKS).

JORDAN LOVE, Green Bay Packers

Grade: A-

Colin's thoughts: "They had 10 drives, they scored on five, on the road. If you're a young quarterback, in the biggest start of your career, you're on the road — I thought he managed the game well."

Odds to know: Packers coach Matt LaFleur has the second-shortest odds to win NFL Coach of the Years at +1300, behind only Detroit's Dan Campbell at +950 (FDS).

share

Get more from National Football League Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more

in this topic

Gambling

National Football League

C.J. Stroud

Houston Texans

Bryce Young

Carolina Panthers

Anthony Richardson

Indianapolis Colts

Deshaun Watson

Cleveland Browns

Jordan Love

Green Bay Packers

Kenny Pickett

Pittsburgh Steelers

Baker Mayfield

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Derek Carr

New Orleans Saints

Joshua Dobbs

Arizona Cardinals

Desmond Ridder

Atlanta Falcons

Sam Howell

Washington Commanders

Las Vegas Raiders

Jimmy Garoppolo

Colin Cowherd

The Herd with Colin Cowherd